Press coverage of gendered labour division in the water sector of Uzbekistan

M. A. Bozorova

Mirzo UlugbekNational University of Uzbekistan, Uzbekistan, 100174, Tashkent, University str., 4.  

E-mail: mahzuna.bozorova@gmail.com

https://doi.org/10.29258/CAJWR/2020-R1.v6-2/42-65.eng

Information Article

Abstract

The article analyses the press coverage of gendered labour division in Uzbekistan’s water sector.  The study focused on the content, types, methods, forms, techniques and principles of gendered labour division coverage in the Narodnoye Slovo [Popular Word], Pravda Vostoka [The Truth of the East], and Darakchi [The Reporter] newspaper periodicals.  The research aimed to review the activities and approaches of Uzbekistan’s press to covering gendered labour division in the water sector, stereotypes in covering the topic, and ways to eliminate them.  Three theoretical approaches were applied to the essence of journalism – i.e. agenda setting, framing and altercasting – to fulfill this task.  The results of monitoring press materials indicate that whereas males more often serve as lead characters of publications as water management specialists, women are mostly depicted as housewives.

Download the article

For citation: Bozorova, M. A. (2020). Press Coverage of Gendered Labour Division in the Water Sector of Uzbekistan. Central Asian Journal of Water Research, 6(2), 42–65. https://doi.org/10.29258/CAJWR/2020-R1.v6-2/42-65.eng

References

  1. 65 yoshli fukaroning balik tutishga ishtiyoki fogia bilan tugadi [The fishing passion of a 65-year-old male citizen ended in tragedy] // Darakchi, July 4, 2019.  Available at: https://darakchi.uz/uz/72564 [In Uzbek, accessed January 10, 2020);
  2. A Manual on Communications for Water Supply and Environmental Sanitation Programmes. Water, Environment and Sanitation Technical Guidelines, 1999. No. 7. UNICEF, p. 7;
  3. Ali, Z.S., 2014.  Visual representation of gender in flood coverage of Pakistani print media, Weather and Climate Extremes, Vol. 4, pp. 35-49.  doi: 10.1016/j. wace.2014.04.001;
  4. Altheide, D., 1996.  Qualitative media analysis.  Sage, Newbury Park;
  5. Amudaryo deltasida kichik suv khavzalari barpo etilmokda [Small basins under establishment built in the Amu Darya delta] // Darakchi, August 20, 2019.  Available at: https://darakchi.uz/uz/73772 [In Uzbek, accessed January 1, 2020];
  6. Amy, J.P., Jennifer, D., 2012.  Freshwater availability and water fetching distance affect child health in sub-Saharan Africa, Environmental Science & Technology, Vol. 46(4), pp. 2391-2397;
  7. Arowolo, O., 2017.  Understanding Framing Theory, unpublished, Lagos State University, Nigeria. doi: 10,13140 / RG.2.2.25800.52482;
  8. Asian Development Bank (ADB), 2015.  Surkhandarya Water Supply and Sanitation Project, UZB: L2492/2493;
  9. Asrorov, U., Elmurodov, M., Zhonibekov, Z., Mamatraimov, H.  Razvitiye Surkhandarji sviazano s ratsionalnym ispolzovaniyem prirodnyh resursov i imeyushchikhsia vozmozhnostej [Surkhandarya’s development depends on the rational use of natural resources and available opportunities] // Pravda Vostoka, May 1, 2019.  Available at: https://www.pv.uz/ru/newspapers/pravda-vostoka-89-ot-1-maja-2019 [In Russian, accessed January 1, 2020];
  10. Bashlayev K.  Voda prihodit v doma [Water enters homes] // Pravda Vostoka, October 18, 2019.  Available at: https://www.pv.uz/ru/newspapers/voda-prihodit-v-doma [In Russian, accessed January 1, 2020];
  11. Bashlayev, K., 2019.  Atirgul Khalmirzayeva – hranitelnitsa sada [Atirgul Khalmirzayeva – the garden keeper] // Pravda Vostoka, July 16, 2019.  Available at: https://www.pv.uz/ru/newspapers/atirgul-halmirzaeva-hranitelnitsa-sada [In Russian, accessed January 1, 2020];
  12. Bashlayev, K., 2019.  Nelegalnyj frilans… u arykov [Illegal freelance… along the aryks] // Pravda Vostoka, April 8, 2019.  Available at: https://www.pv.uz/ru/newspapers/ nelegalnyj-frilans-u-arykov [In Russian, accessed January 1, 2020];
  13. Bennett, V., Dávila-Poblete, S., Rico Nieves, M., 2008.  Water and gender: the unexpected connection that really matters, Journal of International Affairs, Vol. 61, No. 2, pp. 107-126;
  14. Berger, A.A., 1982.  Media analysis techniques.  Sage, Newbury Park;
  15. Boshbekova, K.  Gidroterapiyaning muzhizavij kuchi [The Wonderful Power of Hydrotherapy] // Darakchi, September 26, 2018. Available at: https://darakchi.uz/uz/57797 [In Uzbek, accessed January 12, 2020];
  16. Brown, J.D., Campbell, K.L., Fischer, L., 1986.  American Adolescents and Music Videos: Why Do They Watch?, Gazette, Vol. 37, No. 1-2, pp. 19-32;
  17. Communication Theories (2003-2004).  Available at: www.utwente.nl/communication-theories [accessed December 12, 2019];
  18. Crow, B., McPike, J., 2009.  How the drudgery of getting water shapes women’s lives in low-income urban communities, Gender Technology and Development, Vol. 13, No. 1, pp. 43-68;
  19. Demie, G., Bekele, M., Seyoum, B., 2016.  Water accessibility impact on girl and women’s participation in education and other development activities: the case of Wuchale and Jidda Woreda, Ethiopia, Environmental Systems Research, Vol. 5, No. 1, p.11.  Available at: https://doi.org/10.1186/s40068-016-0061-6;
  20. Entman, R.M., 1993.  Framing: Toward clarification of a fractured paradigm, Journal of Communication, Vol. 43, No. 4, pp. 51-58;
  21. Fargona viloyati pakhta rezhasini birinchi bulib bazhardi [Ferghana Region is the first to fulfill the cotton plan] // Darakchi, October 12, 2019.  Available at: https://darakchi. uz/uz/76246 [In Uzbek, accessed January 10, 2020];
  22. Firibgarlikka kul urgan suvchiga zhazo tayinlandi [A water worker accused of fraud imposed a penalty] // Darakchi, October 9, 2019.  Available at: https://darakchi.uz/uz/ 75938 [In Uzbek, accessed January 10, 2020];
  23. Fisher, J., 2008.  Women in water supply, sanitation and hygiene programmes. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers, Municipal Engineer, Vol. 161, No. 4, pp. 223-229.  doi: 10.1680/muen.2008.161.4.223;
  24. Fiske, S.T., Taylor, S.E., 2010.  Social cognition.  2nd ed.  McGraw-Hill, NY;
  25. Galiyev, R. Tsennost kazhdoj kapli presnoj vody [The value of each drop of fresh water] // Pravda Vostoka, November 7, 2019.  Available at: https://www.pv.uz/ru/ newspapers/tsennost-kazhdoj-kapli-presnoj-vody- [In Russian, accessed January 1, 2020];
  26. Garcia, L., 1998.  Strategy for integrated water resources management.  ENV-125 Sustainable Development Department, Interamerican Development Bank.  DC, Washington;
  27. Gender, agriculture and rural development in Uzbekistan, 2019.  Country Gender Assessment Series.  FAO, Budapest;
  28. Goodall, H., 2012.  Media’s Influence on Gender Stereotypes, Media Asia, Vol. 39, No. 3, pp. 160-163.  doi: 10.1080/01296612.2012.11689932;
  29. Gulyamova, D.  Osvaivaya agrarnye prostory [Mastering the agricultural expanses] // Pravda Vostoka, April 14, 2019.  Available at: https://www.pv.uz/ru/newspapers/ osvaivaja-agrarnye-prostory [In Russian, accessed January 13, 2020];
  30. History in Stories: Gender and Water in Uzbekistan.  Philippines: ABR, 2013, p. 6;
  31. Islamov, U., Maksudov, F., Maksudova, D., 2009.  “Integrated water resources management issues in Uzbekistan” in Water resources management in Central Asia: Regional and international issues at stake, Serie: Asia Número 25, Barcelona, pp. 57-76;
  32. Kanoatov, E., 2018.  Orol dengizi kurishini kishlok kariyalari aldindan bilganmi? [Did the seniors know about the drying of the Aral Sea?] // Darakchi, October 4, 2018.  Available at: https://darakchi.uz/uz/58260 [In Uzbek, accessed January 9, 2020];
  33. Karshiyev, R., Akramov, I., 2019.  Kapelnoye orosheniye okhvatit million gektarov [Drip irrigation to cover a million hectares] // Pravda Vostoka, April 24, 2019.  Available at: https://www.pv.uz/ru/news/kapelnoe-oroshenie-ohvatit-million-gektarov [In Russian, accessed January 11, 2020];
  34. Kasperson, R.E., Kasperson J.X., 1996.  The social amplification and attenuation of risk, The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, Vol. 545, pp. 95-105;
  35. Kechin, A., 2019.  Yaponskij opyt v sadovodstve [Japanese horticulture experiences] // Narodnoye Slovo, July 25, 2019.  Available at: http://xs.uz/ru/post/yaponskij-opyt-v-sadovodstve [In Russian, accessed January 12, 2020];
  36. Kenzhayev, R.  U pustyni – ni yedinogo shansa [No chance for desert] // Narodnoye Slovo, January 8, 2019.  Available at: http://xs.uz/ru/post/save-aral [In Russian, accessed January 11, 2020];
  37. Khandker, V., Gandhi, V.P., Johnson, N., 2020.  Gender Perspective in Water Management: The Involvement of Women in Participatory Water Institutions of Eastern India, Water, Vol. 12, No. 1, p. 196;
  38. Khitarishvili, T., 2016.  Gender inequalities in labour markets in Central Asia.  UNDP, Kazakhstan;
  39. Krijnen, T., 2020.  “Gender and Media” in K. Ross, I. Bachmann, V. Cardo, S. Moorti, M. Scarcelli The International Encyclopedia of Gender, Media, and Communication, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., NY, pp. 1-9.  doi: 10.1002/9781119429128.iegmc016;
  40. Lemish, D., 2012. “Gender: Representation in the Media” in W. Donsbach (ed.), The International Encyclopedia of Communication, 1st Ed., John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, NY. doi:10.1002/9781405186407.wbiecg008.pub2;
  41. Luis, S.P, Ian, C, Iacovos, I., 2002.  Coping with water scarcity, IHP-VI-Technical Documents in Hydrology, No. 58. UNESCO, Paris;
  42. Lyskovsky, E.V., 2017.  Lingvisticheskiye osobennosti tekstov politicheskogo diskursa anglijskogo yazyka [The linguistic features of political discourse texts in the English language].  Tomsk: National Research Tomsk State University (NITGU), 2017, p. 9;
  43. Mamutov, R.  2030 yilgacha akholining 91 foizi toza ichimlik suvi bilan taminlanadi [By 2030, 91% of the population will be provided with clean drinking water] // Darakchi, November 17, 2019.  Available at: https://darakchi.uz/uz/78982 [In Uzbek, accessed January 10, 2020];
  44. Marwell, G., Schmitt, D.R., 1967.  Dimensions of Compliance-Gaining Behavior: An Empirical Analysis, Sociometry, Vol. 30, No. 4, p. 350.  doi: 10.2307/2786181;
  45. Mayeda, A.M., Boyd, A.D., Paveglio, T.B., Flint, C.G., 2018.  Media Representations of Water Issues as Health Risks, Environmental Communication, pp. 1-17.  doi: 10.1080/17524032.2018.1513054;
  46. McCombs, M., 2003.  The Agenda-Setting Role of the Mass Media in the Shaping of Public Opinion, Available at: https://www.infoamerica.org/documentos_ pdf/ mccombs01.pdf [accessed June 10, 2020];
  47. McCombs, M., Valenzuela, S., 2007.  The Agenda-Setting Theory, Cuadernos de Información, Vol. 20, pp. 44-50;
  48. Mezhdunarodnyj den selskih zhenshhin budet otmechatsya v strane kazhdoye 15 oktiabria [The International Day of Rural Women will be celebrated nationwide on October 15] // Narodnoye Slovo, October 3, 2019.  Available at: http://xs.uz/ru/post/ mezhdunarodnyj-den-selskikh-zhenschin-budet-otmechatsya-v-strane-kazhdoe-15-oktyabrya [In Russian, accessed January 10, 2020];
  49. Mikhailov, S. 2019.  Yesli est mechta, to vse poluchitsya [If there is a dream, then everything will work out] // Pravda Vostoka, March 5, 2019.  Available at: https://www.pv.uz/ ru/newspapers/esli-est-mechta-to-vse-poluchitsja [In Russian, accessed January 1, 2020];
  50. Shavkat Mirziyoyev: Pribylnost – osnovnoj kriterij vo vseh sferah ekonomiki [Shavkat Mirziyoyev: Profitability as the main criterion for all sectors of the economy] // Narodnoye Slovo, May 6, 2019.  Available at: http://xs.uz/ru/post/shavkat-mirziyoev-pribylnost-osnovnoj-kriterij-vo-vsekh-sferakh-ekonomiki [In Russian, accessed January 10, 2020];
  51. Multi-indicator cluster research in Uzbekistan.  Final Report, Tashkent, 2006. UNICEF and State Committee on Statistics of the Republic of Uzbekistan, 2007.  Available at:  www.childinfo.org/files/MICS3_Uzbekistan_FinalReport_ 2006_Eng.pdf [In Russian, accessed December 10, 2019];
  52. Muradov, S.  Voda, kotoraya ispolzuyetsia ratsionalno [The water used rationally] // Pravda Vostoka, September 24, 2019.  Available at: https://www.pv.uz/ru/ newspapers/voda-kotoraja-ispolzuetsja-ratsionalno [In Russian, accessed January 11, 2020];  
  53. Nurullayeva, Sh., 2019.  10 nafar yosh fermerlar Yaponiyada malaka oshirib kaitadi [10 young farmers will undergo internship in Japan] // Darakchi, July 25, 2019.  Available at: https://darakchi.uz/uz/73231 [In Uzbek, accessed January 10, 2020];
  54. Official website of the Ministry of Agriculture of the Republic of Uzbekistan.  Available at: http://www.agro.uz/ru/ [accessed December 12, 2019];
  55. Official website of the Ministry of Water Management of the Republic of Uzbekistan. Available at: http://www.water.gov.uz/ru/ [accessed January 25, 2020];
  56. Official website of the State Committee on Statistics of the Republic of Uzbekistan.  Available at: https://stat.uz/ru [accessed January 25, 2020];
  57. Opredeleny mery po effektivnomu upravleniyu i ratsionalnomu ispolzovaniyu vodnyh resursov [Measures for the effective management and rational use of water resources identified] // Narodnoye Slovo, September 20, 2019a.  Available at: http://xs.uz/ru/ post/opredeleny-mery-po-effektivnomu-upravleniyu-i-ratsionalnomu-ispolzovaniyu-vodnykh-resursov [In Russian, accessed January 10, 2020];
  58. Opredeleny mery po effektivnomu upravleniyu i ratsionalnomu ispolzovaniyu vodnyh resursov [Measures for the effective management and rational use of water resources identified] // Pravda Vostoka, September 19, 2019b.  Available at: https://www.pv.uz/ ru/news/suv-resurslarini-samarali-boshqarish-va-tejash-boyicha-vazifalar-belgilandi [In Russian, accessed January 12, 2020];
  59. OSCE, 2015.  Zhenshchiny, voda i bezopasnost [Women, water and security].  Available at: https://www.osce.org/ru/secretariat/177976 [In Russian, accessed January 24, 2020];
  60. Otchet vypolneniya polozhenij pekinskoj deklaratsiyi i platformy dejstvij Uzbekistanom. 25-ya godovshhina provedeniya Chetvertoj Vsemirnoj konferentsiyi po polozheniyu zhenshchin i priniatiya Pekinskoj deklaratsiyi i Platformy dejstvij [Report on the implementation of provisions of the Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action by Uzbekistan.  25th anniversary of the 4th World Conference on Women and endorsement of the Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action.  Tashkent., 2019, p. 13 [In Russian];
  61. Pokazateli ekonomicheski aktivnogo naseleniya [Economically Active Population Indices], 2018.  Available at: https://gender.stat.uz/en/osnovnye-pokazateli/trud/active-population/ 1020-3464564 [In Russian, accessed December 10, 2019];
  62. Poverty and Social Assessment of Water Supply and Sanitation Project in Bukhara, Navoi Provinces and Fergana Valley. Consultant’s Report. Manila, TA 7240 UZB, 2010, p. 57;
  63. Prezident pobesedoval s aktivom Syrdarinskoj oblasti [The President had a talk with the activists of Syrdarya Region] // Narodnoye Slovo, July 19, 2019.  Available at: http://xs.uz/ru/post/prezident-pobesedoval-s-aktivom-syrdarinskoj-oblasti [In Russian, accessed January 11, 2019];
  64. Prezident pobesedoval s fermerami [The president had a talk with farmers] // Narodnoye Slovo, July 26, 2019.  Available at: http://xs.uz/ru/post/prezident-pobesedoval-s-fermerami [In Russian, accessed January 12, 2019];
  65. Quesnel, K.J., Ajami, N.K., 2017.  Changes in water consumption linked to heavy news media coverage of extreme climatic events, Science Advances, Vol. 3, No. 10.  doi: 10.1126/sciadv.1700784;
  66. Rakhimov, S., 2009.  “Impacts of climate change on water resources in Central Asia” in Water resources management in Central Asia: Regional and international issues at stake, Serie: Asia Número 25, Barcelona, pp. 33-56;
  67. Rayony Dzhizakskoi oblasti budut obespecheny vodoj iz reki Zarafshan [Districts of Jizzak Region will be supplied water from the Zarafshan River] // Narodnoye Slovo, January 31, 2019.  Available at: http://xs.uz/ru/post/rajony-dzhizakskoj-oblasti-budut-obespecheny-vodoj-iz-reki-zarafshan [In Russian, accessed January 13, 2020];
  68. Report of the Ministry of Agriculture, 2019.  The 2nd Forum of Women Farmers of Uzbekistan.  Tashkent, February 21, 2019;
  69. Rostekh pomozhet obespechit Uzbekistan pityevoj vodoj [Rostec will help providing Uzbekistan with potable water] // Pravda Vostoka, September 12, 2019.  Available at: https://www.pv.uz/ru/news/holding-shvabe-obespechit-uzbekistan-pitevoj-vodoj [In Russian, accessed January 12, 2020];
  70. Samarkandi suv omborida 300 tonna balik nobud buldi [About 300 tons of fish died in the Samarkand Reservoir] // Darakchi, August 30, 2018.  Available at: https://darakchi.uz/uz/56544 [In Uzbek, accessed January 10, 2020];
  71. Scheufele, D.A., Shanahan, J., Kim, S.H., 2002.  Who cares about local politics?  Media influences on local political involvement, issue awareness, and attitude strength, Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly, Vol. 79, pp. 427-444;
  72. Shamollashdan tez va oson khalos bulish usuli [Fast and simple way to get rid of a cold] // Darakchi, November 29, 2019.  Available at: https://darakchi.uz/uz/79950 [In Uzbek, accessed January 12, 2020];
  73. Shrestha, S., Chapagain, P.S., Ghimire, M., 2019.  Gender Perspective on Water Use and Management in the Context of Climate Change: A Case Study of Melamchi Watershed Area, Nepal, SAGE Open, Vol. 9, No. 1.  doi: 10.1177/2158244018823078;
  74. Sidorskaya, I., Radu, A., 2014.  Gender i SMI [Gender and the Mass Media].  Minsk: National Institute for Higher Education (RIVSh), 2014, p. 134;
  75. Statistika ob obespechennosti kvartir (domov) kanalizaciej po regionam [Statistics on sewage supply of apartments (houses) by regions].  Available at: https://stat.uz/en/164 -ofytsyalnaia-statyka-ru/6583-district-environment [In Russian, accessed December 10, 2019];
  76. Statistika ob obespechennosti kvartir (domov) pitjevoj vodoj po regionam [Statistics on drinking water supply of apartments (houses) by regions].  Available at: https://stat.uz/en/ 164-ofytsyalnaia-statyka-ru/6583-district-environment [In Russian, accessed December 10, 2019];
  77. Suvdan nokonunij foydalanish zhinoyatga etakladi [Illegal water use had led to a crime] / Darakchi, November 20, 2019.  Available at: https://darakchi.uz/uz/79233 [In Uzbek, accessed January 14, 2020];
  78. Suvga nokonunij ulangan fukaro kilgan ishidan pushajmon buldi [A citizen who had illegally tapped into the water supply line regrets his deed] // Darakchi, October 28, 2019.  Available at: https://darakchi.uz/uz/77437 [In Uzbek, accessed January 10, 2020];
  79. Suvni tugri ichish insultni aldini oladi [Proper water consumption can prevent strokes] // Darakchi, October 21, 2019.  Available at: https://darakchi.uz/uz/76882 [In Uzbek, accessed January 10, 2020];
  80. Toshkentdagi 600 ga yakin akholi uchun 4 km.ga ichimlik suvi kuvuri yotkizilmokda [4 km of water piping is installed for about 600 Tashkent residents] // Darakchi, November 6, 2019.  Available at: https://darakchi.uz/uz/78179 [In Uzbek, accessed January 10, 2020];
  81. Treshalov, G.  Proekt po mikroGES pomozhet zhiteljam otdalennyh rajonov [Micro-HPP project will help residents of remote communities] // Pravda Vostoka, June 7, 2019.  Available at: https://www.pv.uz/ru/news/proekt-po-mikroges [In Russian, accessed January 10, 2020];
  82. Tugri ovkatlanish uchun 5 tavsiya [5 Recommendations for Proper Nutrition] // Darakchi, August 14, 2018.  Available at: https://darakchi.uz/uz/55786 [In Uzbek, accessed January 10, 2020];
  83. Uchastiye zhenshchin v upravlenii vodoj [Women’s participation in water management] // Ekonomicheskoye Obozreniye, 2019.  Available at: https://www.review.uz/ru/post/staty/ trendi/uchastie-jenshin-v-upravlenii-vodoy [In Russian, accessed December 12, 2019];
  84. Ulugmurodov, D., 2018.  I prishla voda v Bajsun [And there came water to Baisun] // Narodnoye Slovo, November 8, 2018.  Available at: http://xs.uz/ru/post/water-baysun [In Russian, accessed January 10, 2020];
  85. V Uzbekistane vpervye otmechajut Den rabotnikov selskogo hozyajstva [For the first time Uzbekistan celebrates the Agricultural Worker’s Day] // Darakchi, December 10, 2017.  Available at: https://darakchi.uz/ru/39591 [In Russian, accessed January 9, 2020];
  86. Wahaj, R., Hartl, M., 2007.  Gender and Water.  Securing Water for Improved Rural Livelihoods: The multiple-uses system approach.  IFAD, Rome.  Available at:  https://reliefweb.int/report/world/gender-and-water-securing-water-improved-rural-livelihoodsmultiple-uses-system;
  87. Wood, J.T., 2013.  Gendered Media: The Influence of Media on Views of Gender, pp. 31-41.  Available at: https://www.nyu.edu/classes/jackson/causes.of.gender.inequality/ Readings/Wood%20-%20Gendered%20Media%20-%2094.pdf;
  88. Yakubov, S., 2019.  Lovis, rybka, i bolshaja, i …morskaya [Bite, oh fish, big and… marine] // Pravda Vostoka, February 22, 2019.  Available at: https://www.pv.uz/ru/ news/lovis-rybka-i-bolshaja-i-morskaja [In Russian, accessed January 11, 2020];
  89. Zwarteveen, M., 2008.  Men, Masculinities and Water Powers in Irrigation, Water Alternatives, Vol. 1, No. 1, pp. 111-130;
  90. Zwarteveen, M., 2010.  The politics of gender in water and the gender of water politics. University of Amsterdam.  Available at:  https://www.researchgate.net/publication/ 46385492_The_politics_of_gender_in_water_and_the_gender_of_water_politics  [accessed July 10, 2020].
Post Views: 2,366

gender, Media, press, Uzbekistan, water sector