State-facilitated bottom up in agricultural water governance and sustainability of solutions to recurring water stress: a case study from smallholders’ perspective in Uzbekistan
Davron Niyazmetov1*, Ilkhom Soliev1, Inna Rudenko2
1 Martin Luther University of Halle-Wittenberg, 06099 Halle (Saale), Germany
2 NGO “KRASS”, Urgench State University, 14, Khamid Olimjan street, Urgench, Uzbekistan
* Corresponding author: firstname.lastname@example.org
Agricultural water stress is a critical problem undermining socioeconomic development and environmental sustainability of water and land resources in many agriculture-based economies. Uzbekistan is an example of such case, where for coping with the problem, water reforms such as creation of Water User Associations (WUAs) attempted to decentralize the decision-making to some extent encouraging bottom-up approach to water governance. However, the results have been disappointing so far, particularly visible in persistence of priority in water allocation for farmers with state-ordered crops and neglect of smallholders as legitimate water users. The study presented here describes some of the discrepancies between paper and practice in the example of water governance in one studied community. Using household survey, interviews, and focus group discussion, the authors show that true transformation into bottom up cannot be achieved through pure state-facilitation, especially if it remains on paper and largely limited to technical measures. Such state-facilitated bottom up is bound to fail with the arrival of new levels of water stress. Preferential treatment also undermines incentives of farmers to improve productivity in using water and land resources. The authors highlight that a balanced attention is needed in relation to reforms that encourage not only supply-side solutions, even though they are very necessary. Reforms are also necessary directed at enabling smallholders to participate in decision-making in dealing with water stress, and take more active role in communicating their needs, negotiating fair allocation, and coordinating implementation of agreed water plans.Download the article
How to cite: Niyazmetov, D., Soliev, I., & Rudenko, I. (2019). State-facilitated bottom up in agricultural water governance and sustainability of solutions to recurring water stress: a case study from smallholders’ perspective in Uzbekistan. Central Asian Journal of Water Research, 5(1), 42–57. https://doi.org/10.29258/cajwr/2019-r1.v5-1/42-57.eng
- Abdullaev, I., Kazbekov, J., Manthritilake, H. and Jumaboev, K., 2010, “Water user groups in Central Asia: emerging form of collective action in irrigation water management”, Journal of Water Resources Management, Vol. 24, No. 5, pp.1029-1043.
- Abdullaev, I. and Mollinga, P., 2010, “The socio-technical aspects of water management: emerging trends at grass roots level in Uzbekistan”, Water, Vol. 2, No. 1, pp. 85-100.
- Abdullaev I., Nurmetova F., Abdullaeva F. & Lamers J., 2008, “Socio-technical aspects of water management in Uzbekistan: emerging water governance issues at the grass root level”, in Rahaman, M.M. & Varis O. (Eds.), Central Asian Waters: Social, economic, environmental and governance puzzle, Helsinki University of Technology – TKK, Helsinki, Finland, pp. 89-103.
- Abdullaev, I. and Rakhmatullaev, S., 2015, “Transformation of water management in Central Asia: from State-centric, hydraulic mission to socio-political control”, Environmental Earth Sciences, Vol. 73, No. 2, pp. 849-861.
- Akramkhanov, A., and Vlek, P., 2011, “The assessment of spatial distribution of soil salinity risk using neural network”, Environmental monitoring and assessment, Vol. 184, No. 4, pp. 2475-2485.
- Aminova, M. and Abdullaev, I., 2009, “Water management in a state-centered environment: water governance analysis of uzbekistan”, Sustainability, Vol. 1, No. 4, pp. 1240-1265.
- Amirova, I., Petrick, M. and Djanibekov N., 2019, “Long- and short-term determinants of water user cooperation: Experimental evidence from Central Asia”, World Development, Vol. 113, pp. 10-25.
- Bryman, A., 2012, Social research methods. 4th ed. New York, Oxford University Press.
- Djanibekov, N., Van Assche, K., Bobojonov, I. and Lamers, J.P., 2012, “Farm restructuring and land consolidation in Uzbekistan: New farms with old barriers”. Europe-Asia Studies, Vol 64, No. 6, pp.1101-1126.
- Djumaboev, K., Anarbekov, O., Holmatov, B. and Hamidov, A., 2017, “Overview of water-related programs in Uzbekistan”, Project report of the Sustainable Management of Water Resources in Rural Areas in Uzbekistan. Component 1: National policy framework for water governance and integrated water resources management and supply part, Colombo, Sri Lanka: International Water Management Institute (IWMI).
- Gunchinmaa, T. and Yakubov, M., 2010, “Institutions and transition: does a better institutional environment make water users associations more effective in Central Asia?”, Water Policy, Vol. 12, No. 2, pp. 165-185.
- Hamidov, A., Thiel, A. and Zikos, D., 2015, “Institutional design in transformation: A comparative study of local irrigation governance in Uzbekistan”, Environmental Science and Policy, Vol. 53, Part B, pp. 175-191.
- Horinkova, V. and Abdullaev, I., 2003, “Institutional aspects of water management in Central Asia water users associations”, Water international, Vol. 28, No. 2, pp. 237-245.
- Jones, N. A., Ross, H., Lynam, T., Perez, P. and Leitch A., 2011, “Mental models: an interdisciplinary synthesis of theory and methods”, Ecology and Society, Vol. 16, No 1: 46.
- Kim, E. and Hornidge, A., 2016, “IWRM in Uzbekistan: a global concept with local consequences”, in Borchardt, D., Ibisch, R. & Bogardi, J. (Eds.), Integrated Water Resources Management: Concept, Research and Implementation,Springer, Switzerland, pp. 201-219.
- Moss, T. and Hamidov, A., 2016, “Where water meets agriculture: the ambivalent role of water users associations”, in Hüttl, R., Bens, O., Bismuth, C. & Hoechstetter S., (Eds.), Society-Water-Technology: A critical appraisal of major water engineering projects, Springer Open, Switzerland, pp. 149-167.
- Mukhamedova, N. and Wegerich, K, 2014, “Integration of villages into WUAs – the rising challenge for local water management in Uzbekistan”, International Journal of Water Governance, Vol. 2, pp. 153-170.
- Oberkircher, L., Tischbein, B., Hornidge, A., Schorcht, G., Bhaduri, A., Awan, U. and Manschadi, A., 2010, “Rethinking water management in Khorezm, Uzbekistan: Concepts and recommendations”, ZEF working paper series, #54.
- Ohlsson, L. R. and Turton, A., 2000, “The turning of a screw: social resource scarcity as a bottle-neck in adaptation to water scarcity”, Stockholm Water Front, Vol. 1.
- Petrick, M. and Djanibekov, N., 2019, “Farm restructuring in Uzbekistan: What next?”, Leibniz Institute of Agricultural Development in Transition Economies, Policy brief, #36.
- Sangameswaran, P., 2009, “Neoliberalism and water reforms in western India: Commercialization, self-sufficiency, and regulatory bodies”, Geoforum, Vol.40, pp. 228-238.
- Sehring, J., 2009, “Path dependencies and institutional bricolage in post‐Soviet water governance”, Water Alternatives, Vol. 2, No 1, pp. 61-81.
- Soliev, I., Theesfeld, I., Wegerich, K. and Platonov, A., 2017, “Dealing with “baggage” in riparian relationship on water allocation: a longitudinal comparative study from the ferghana valley”, Ecological Economics, Vol. 142, pp. 148-162.
- Soliev, I., Wegerich, K. and Kazbekov, J., 2015, “The costs of benefit sharing: historical and institutional analysis of shared water development in the Ferghana Valley, the Syr Darya Basin”, Water, Vol.7, No 6, pp. 2728-2752.
- State Committee on Statistics of Uzbekistan, 2016, Available at: https://stat.uz/en/435-analiticheskie-materialy-en1/2070-key-indicators-of-agricultural-sector, [5 May, 2019].
- Swinkels, R., Romanova, E. & Kochkin, E., 2016, Exploratory assessment of factors that influence quality of local irrigation water governance in Uzbekistan. World Bank, Washington, USA.
- Thaler, R.H., 1999, “Mental accounting matters”, Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, Vol. 12, No 3, pp. 183-206.
- Theesfeld, I., 2004, “Constraints on Collective Action in a Transitional Economy: The Case of Bulgaria’s Irrigation Sector”, World Development, Vol. 32, No. 2, pp. 251-271.
- Theesfeld, I. and MacKinnon, A., 2014, “Giving birds a starting date: The curious social solution to a water resource issue in the U.S. West”, Ecological Economics, Vol. 97, pp. 110-119.
- Theesfeld, I. and Jelinek, L., 2017, “A misfit in policy to protect Russia’s black soil region. An institutional analytical lens applied to the ban on burning of crop residues”, Land Use Policy, Vol. 67, pp. 517-526.
- The Law of Republic of Uzbekistan “O vode i vodopol’zovanii [On water and water use]”, Available at: http://www.lex.uz/ru/docs/93202 [22 April, 2019]. (In Russian).
- Trevisani, T., 2010, Land and Power in Khorezm: Farmers, communities, and the state in Uzbekistan’s decollectivization. Lit Verlag, Berlin.
- Veldwisch, G., 2008, “Cotton, rice and water: the transformation of agrarian relations, irrigation technology, and water distribution in Khorezm, Uzbekistran”, PhD thesis, Department of Philosophy, Rheinischen Friedrich-Wilhelms-University, Bonn.
- Veldwisch, G., Mollinga, P., Hirsh, D. and Yalcin, R., 2012, “Politics of agricultural management in Khorezm, Uzbekistan” in Martius, C., Rudenko, I., Lamers, J.P.A. and Vlek, P.L.G. (Eds.), Cotton, water, salts and soums: Economic and ecological restructuring in Khorezm, Uzbekistan, Springer, Dordrecht, Netherlands, pp. 127-140.
- Veldwisch, G. and Mollinga P., 2013, “Lost in transition? The introduction of water users associations in Uzbekistan”, Water International, Vol. 38, No. 6, pp. 758–773.
- Wegerich, K., 2003, “Water: the difficult path to a sustainable future for Central Asia”, in Everett-Heath, T. (Ed.), Central Asia: Aspects of Transition, Routledge, London, pp. 244-263.
- Wegerich, K., 2008, “Blueprints for water user associations’ accountability versus local reality: evidence from South Kazakhstan”, Water International, Vol. 33, No. 1, pp. 43-54.
- Wegerich, K., Van Rooijen, D., Soliev, I. and Mukhamedova, N., 2015, “Water security in the Syr Darya Basin”, Water, Vol. 7, No 9, pp. 4657-4684.
- Williamson, O., 2000, “The New Institutional Economics: Take Stock, Looking Ahead”, Journal of Economic Literature, Vol. 38, No. 3, pp. 595-613.
- Yakubov, M. and Ul-Hassan, M., 2007, “Mainstreaming rural poor in water resources management: preliminary lessons of a bottom-up WUA development approach in Central Asia”, Irrigation and Drainage, Vol. 56, No 2, pp. 261–276.
- Zinzani, A., 2016, “Hydraulic bureaucracies and irrigation management transfer in Uzbekistan: The case of Samarkand Province”, International Journal of Water Resources Development, Vol. 32, No. 2, pp. 232-246.